Dodgy Public Sector Investments?
A detailed breakdown of questionable public sector investments across UK councils, health trusts, universities, and more, grouped by institution type and listing specific companies, sectors, and controversies:
Council Pension Funds
Derbyshire County Council
Fossil Fuels: Shell, BP, ConocoPhillips
Arms: Raytheon (cluster munitions), Lockheed Martin (nuclear weapons), Boeing (fighter jets)
Tobacco: British American Tobacco, Philip Morris
Mining: Rio Tinto, Glencore (pollution, child labour)
Essex County Council
Military-Linked Firms: BAE Systems (Yemen strikes), Tata Group (Myanmar arms)
Controversial Commodities: Glencore (corruption), BAT tobacco (health harms)
Deflection: Prioritises “maximum return” despite human rights concerns
Isle of Wight Council
Complicity Claims: £31.8m allegedly invested in firms tied to Israeli military
Response: Raised in Palestine Solidarity Campaign meetings
Sefton Council
Motion Passed: Divest from fossil fuels and arms in April 2025
Justification: Climate emergency and ethical governance
Wandsworth Council
Fund Value: £3.2 billion
Issues: Poor performance, alleged concealment, investment in underperforming equity/property funds
NHS Trusts and PFIs
Barts Health NHS Trust
PFI Contracts: Pays >£100 million/year to private contractors
Ownership: Several entities linked to offshore accounts and tax havens
General NHS Concerns
PFIs: High interest rates, opaque procurement
Example Contractors: Carillion (bankrupted), Skanska (labour violations)
Universities
University of Birmingham, Leeds, Imperial College
Holdings: Shell, BP, ExxonMobil
Ranking: Low scores on People & Planet’s Fossil Free Scorecard
Pushback: Alumni and student divestment campaigns
Cambridge and Oxford (partial divestment)
Remaining Holdings: Private equity in fossil-linked hedge funds and big pharma
Ethical Audits: Often hidden from public view
Transport Sector
Transport for London (TfL)
Property Deals: Partnered with developers accused of worker exploitation
Rail Bailouts: Abellio and Arriva tied to Dutch/Spanish tax havens
National Rail Franchises
Controversies: Govia (fare misreporting), Stagecoach (disqualified from HS2 bidding)
Science and Innovation Grants
Innovate UK and UKRI
Shell Firms: Grants occasionally awarded to opaque entities
Examples: AI firms with no registered staff or vague technical deliverables
Oversight Issues: Minimal post-award review
Local Authority Investment Schemes
Thurrock Council
Losses: £655 million in failed solar bond investments
Linked Entity: Liam Kavanagh’s Rockfire group
Croydon Council
Bankruptcy 2020: High-risk property borrowing and mismanagement
Spelthorne Council
Debt Load: £1 billion+ borrowed for commercial property with declining yields
Police and Crime Commissioners
Surveillance Tech Investments
Firms: Clearview AI, Palantir (privacy violations abroad)
Issues: Hidden procurement contracts, lack of ethical scrutiny
HMRC Pension Fund
Tax Avoidance Conflicts
Indirect Holdings: Cayman-based funds
Irony Noted: Agency in charge of enforcement linked to avoidance vehicles
A draft policy statement for a blanket exclusion of unethical investments in public sector funds, with provisions for quarterly ethical reviews. Feel free to adapt this for a blog, council motion, or open letter:
Ethical Investment Draft Motion: Public Sector Funds
Title: Motion for Blanket Exclusion of Arms, Fossil Fuels, Tobacco, and Human Rights-Violating Entities in Public Sector Investment Portfolios
Proposer: [Insert Name or Councillor/Public Group] Date: [Insert Date]
Purpose
To uphold ethical stewardship and align public sector investments with climate, peace, and human rights principles by excluding specified sectors and enhancing transparency through quarterly oversight.
Exclusion Criteria
All public sector funds, including but not limited to Local Government Pension Schemes (LGPS), must divest from and exclude:
Fossil Fuels:
Oil, gas, and coal extraction companies
Fossil-fuel-based power generation
Pipeline infrastructure corporations
Arms and Weaponry:
Nuclear weapons producers
Cluster munitions manufacturers
Firms supplying military operations in active conflict zones
Tobacco and Nicotine Corporations:
Tobacco cultivation and production companies
Nicotine and Vape product firms targeting underage markets
Human Rights Offenders:
Corporations complicit in war crimes, apartheid, or forced labour or general labour abuses
Entities sanctioned by the UK government or UN for abuses
Gambling Industry
Online betting platforms and casino operators
Firms profiting from addictive gaming models
Companies with poor records on harm reduction or youth exposure
Tax Haven-Linked Entities
Firms domiciled in jurisdictions with secrecy laws or zero corporate tax
Investment vehicles routed through Panama, Jersey, Cayman Islands, etc.
Contractors or suppliers with opaque ownership structures or general tax abuses
Portfolio Audit and Quarterly Review
To enforce this motion:
Conduct a full forensic audit of current holdings within 90 days
Initiate a quarterly ethical review of investment portfolios
Include external experts, civil society observers, and fund members
Publish transparent reports online, with:
Listed exclusions
Rationale for decisions
Any breaches or remedial actions taken
Education and Oversight
Host annual ethical investment forums for fund members
Integrate ethical clauses into procurement and investment tendering
Train committee members in ESG (Environment, Social, Governance) metrics and divestment pathways
Comments