Asia’s Maritime Safety Gap: From Phuket to Halong Bay and the South China Sea

 


Halong Bay Tragedy: A Stark Reminder

This week, a tourist ferry capsized in Halong Bay, Vietnam, during Storm Wipha, claiming 27 lives. Despite decades of regional development, this incident echoes a troubling pattern: Asia’s maritime safety remains uneven, especially in tourist-heavy zones.

Remembering Phuket: The 2004 Tsunami

The Indian Ocean tsunami devastated Phuket and surrounding provinces, killing over 5,400 people in Thailand alone. Beaches like Patong, Kata, and Karon were obliterated. The disaster exposed Thailand’s lack of early warning systems and catalysed sweeping reforms:

  • Installation of tsunami buoys and 130+ warning towers

  • Annual evacuation drills and multilingual alerts

  • Creation of National Disaster Prevention Day on December 26

Yet, two decades later, tourist boat safety still lags behind land-based disaster preparedness.

Maritime Safety: A Regional Patchwork

Since ASEAN’s formation, ferry safety has improved in some nations:

  • China: Fatalities dropped from 90/year to just 4/year by 2019

  • Philippines & Bangladesh: Significant reductions through enforcement and modernization

But others—Indonesia, Myanmar, DR Congo—face rising death tolls due to weak oversight. Tourist vessels often operate with minimal regulation, especially in remote or scenic areas.

From 2002–2016, there were 163 major ferry accidents, resulting in over 17,000 deaths. Bangladesh, Indonesia, and the Philippines were responsible for over 50% of these fatalities.

The global average has hovered around 1,000 deaths per year, though underreporting is common.

Coupled with 300,000 global drowning deaths: 50% in Asia and 25% children under 5, ASEAN has a key role in Boat Safety and School Swimming Lessons.

South China Sea: Water Cannons and Risk Escalation

In 2025, Chinese coast guard vessels used water cannons against Philippine boats in the South China Sea, escalating tensions over disputed waters. These confrontations:

  • Threaten civilian maritime traffic

  • Undermine regional cooperation

  • Divert attention from safety infrastructure gaps

The SCS flashpoints highlight how geopolitical conflict compounds maritime risk, especially for smaller ASEAN nations. While Ghost Fishing Fleets risk IUU problems too.

Bridging the Gap: What ASEAN Must Do

ASEAN’s current maritime safety framework is fragmented. To close the gap:

  • Standardise ferry safety protocols across member states

  • Expand multilingual disaster education, especially for tourists

  • A quarterly ASEAN Action Report on drownings and boat accidents - similar to UK, now with just 226 water deaths per year.

  • Promote data-sharing and joint drills in high-risk zones with SMS texts/sirens - even an ASEAN RNLI and Navy coordination

  • Address climate-linked hazards like typhoons and rising sea levels

Cultural Memory and Policy Urgency

The legacy of Vietnamese boat people, with 250,000 deaths at sea 1975-95, and the Phuket tsunami, with 8,000 deaths in Thailand and 280,000 across the Indian Ocean region, adds emotional weight to maritime safety. These events are not just statistics—they’re cultural scars that demand policy action.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Policy #5: Development not Over-Development

As MP I will halt the development boom of Concrete Kent in Thanet. We are overbuilding far beyond South East targets as mere property speculation for the construction industry. I will insist construction is refocused on renovating both public housing and empty properties: over 3,000 empty properties in Thanet - for years - before one brick is laid on new build. The idea of a 4th Town at Westwood Cross should also be ripped up as property and Planning overkill given vacant properties, an ageing population and a failed economy. And on prime farmland when Climate Change is a major issue and Food Security in preserving our farmland to reduce food imports. And of course major derelict brownfield sites such as Manston airport, Richboro: derelict longer than in operation, and many more. Councils are notorious for being focused on property and construction where the main parties get their kickbacks for handing out Planning permissions. Far greater scrutiny of the Planning system is required. A...
Read more

David Cockburn KCC: Parkway and council corruption

(email to David Cockburn KCC CEO 3/3/21 cc Parliament etc as below) Hi David I and others were surprised at an access road for Kent Parkway rail station planned for 15th March without notice/consultation. As you know from KCC's own research the Parkway was overwhelmingly rejected by the public and councillors. And any rail improvements were less than 90 seconds or so(!). Yes, seconds. It seems a massive KCC civil servant white elephant tarmac scheme again: £20M in Whitehall funds were spent on documents? And is it a leftover of the secret KCC attempts to develop Manston as London International airport with KCC quango funds for the Virginia flights that bellyflopped and resulted in the sacking of your predecessor? Can you halt any works at the site for a call-in review and please provide FOI/EIR documents/emails etc of costs/plans etc of this utterly ludicrous project. For clarity the East Kent aquifer for drinking water for 150k people is under the Manston/Parkway r...
Read more

Tobias MP and Yellow Peril 2.0 for China and 77th Brigade?

The Tobias Ellwood MP article in last week’s Mail on Sunday (and a full page no less) was chilling for several reasons. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-7592503/TOBIAS-ELLWOOD-China-winning-war-West-cyber-space-dark-moon.html The blaring headline of: "From cyber space to the dark side of the moon, China is waging war on the West - and it’s winning" is concerning not just for Pink Floyd fans worried that China’s counterfeit music industry extended from their back catalogue to the Moon itself. But also that a former Defence Minister was peddling such Yellow Peril 2.0 nonsense in the 21st century. And all the more concerning with Tobias not just as a Colonel Blimp eccentric MP hyping up the military and its tax budgets, but somehow extending a minor captaincy in the Army into a Lieutenant-Colonel role in the 77th Brigade, the military psyops function. No doubt Bill Cash MP or the fightin’ bank manager reservist Mark Francois MP, or Nigel Farage already...
Read more